Charles Rocco and Dawn Brehony Secure Summary Judgment in Virginia Builders’ Risk Suit Limitation Dispute

Foran Glennon Shareholder Charles Rocco and Partner Dawn Brehony recently secured summary judgment victory for an insurer client in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia following a dispute over the enforceability of a policy’s suit limitation provision. The District Court rejected the plaintiff’s argument that the builders’ risk policy’s one-year suit limitation provision was unenforceable and dismissed the plaintiff’s action as time barred.

Case Background

The plaintiff was constructing a bridge over the Rappahannock River in Virginia. To aid in construction, the plaintiff constructed a causeway to allow for the movement of various large pieces of equipment used to build the bridge. Due to unexpected increases in water flow to the river, the causeway flooded. The plaintiff made claims for four separate flood losses to the causeway. The plaintiff’s insurer advised the plaintiff that its builders’ risk policy had a $250,000 flood deductible that applied to each loss. Disagreeing with this assessment, the plaintiff filed suit against the insurer more than one year after the last flood loss, seeking damages totaling approximately $1 million.

Relying on the policy’s suit limitation provision, the insurer moved to dismiss the suit as time barred. The provision required any action on the policy to be brought within one year of the occurrence or, at most, one year after discovery by the insured of the occurrence that gave rise to the claim. Virginia Code § 38.2-314 provides that “no provision in any insurance policy shall be valid if it limits the time within which an action may be brought to less than one year after the loss occurs or the cause of action accrues.” The insurer argued that, because the suit limitation provision complied with the statute, it was valid and enforceable. As such, the claim was therefore time barred.

To avoid dismissal of the action, the plaintiff argued that its action was not time barred for two reasons:

  • under Virginia Code 38.2-2100, insurance policies that provide coverage against fire are Statutory Fire Insurance Policies, which require such policies to contain a minimum two-year suit limitation period; and
  • in the alternative, under Virginia Code § 38.2-314, insurance policies require a minimum suit limitation period of one year after the loss occurred and one year after the cause of action accrues. The plaintiff argued that its cause of action against the insurer did not accrue until the insurance company issued its partial denial of the claim and, as such, its action was not time barred.

On reply, the insurer argued two points.

  • First, the policy was a builders’ risk inland marine policy, not a Statutory Fire Insurance Policy. Accordingly, it was not subject to the statutory two-year limitations period.
  • Second, the plaintiff’s reading of Virginia Code § 38.2-314 was distorted. Virginia Code § 38.2-314 allows policies to contain either:
    • (a) a one-year suit limitation from the date of loss; or
    • (b) a one-year suit limitation from the date the cause of action accrues.

The plaintiff’s reading would eliminate the “one year after the loss occurs” option from the statute because the date of loss always precedes the date of accrual. Thus, the policy’s suit limitation provision, requiring any action to be brought within one year after the loss occurs, was valid under Virginia Code § 38.2-314.

The Court’s Decision

The District Court ruled in favor of the insurance company following oral argument.

  • The court determined that the policy was a commercial inland marine policy, not a Statutory Fire Insurance Policy. Therefore, the policy was not subject to the statutory two-year minimum limitations period.
  • Further, the District Court agreed with the insurance company’s reading of Virginia Code § 38.2-314. The court found that the statute allows policies to contain either: (a) a one-year suit limitation from the date of loss; or (b) a one-year suit limitation from the date the cause of action accrues. Accordingly, the District Court found that the policy’s suit limitation provision was valid and enforceable under Virginia law and dismissed the suit as untimely as a matter of law.

Charles and Dawn concentrate their practice in first-party property insurance disputes. Their experience spans a full array of first-party property insurance matters, including bad faith claims, builders’ risk claims, and construction and design defect claims.

Scroll to Top